An Enduring Reason to Paint Miniatures for Money

Painting miniatures for profit, featuring a desk with painting supplies, miniatures, and money, with the text "A New Reason to Paint Miniatures for Money

At some point in your miniature painting journey, you may wonder if you’ve reached a point where you’re considered “good”. Many years ago, I wondered this myself, whether my skills with a brush and paint had reached a level that could be admired and respected by others in the miniature painting community. It sounds vain, thinking that I wanted to know what others thought about my work.

But, for my personality, I felt I needed some objective measure to understand whether I had grown in skill. Art, of course, isn’t a static thing you do. You’re always looking to improve.

Close-up of a hand painting a miniature figure, with the text "A New Reason to Paint Miniatures for Money" on a warm-colored background

Enter money…

—Money is the objective measure we all use to assign value to a product or service. When you pay for a hamburger at your favorite food joint, how much you’re willing to pay is counter-balanced by the quality and service of the product, i.e., the hamburger.

When it comes to judging “things”, money allows a group of people to determine the worth of something.

And, so with money, you can make a case that a product or “widget” is valued to a certain level by an external conglomeration of factors—Here are a few: the demand for the widget; it’s uniqueness in the market place, and whether the consumer places some unknown factor x value on said widget.

MORE: Can you paint miniatures for a living?


The first Reason I started trying to sell my miniature painting service

The first reason I painted miniatures as a commissioned painter was to help my friends get paint on their tabletop wargaming miniatures. At the time, I was a PressGanger (a community organizer) representing Privateer Press for their tabletop wargame, Warmachine-Hordes. I ran events, leagues, and organized tournaments at our local game store.

As anyone knows, painted miniatures are more fun to game with than bare plastic or metal. And, as an avid painter and hobbyist, I loved getting my hands dirty, painting, assembling, and doing all the things that make a wargaming scenario come alive, e.g., making terrain and even writing fan story lore.

warhammer 40k terrain piece - A meticulously painted war fortress miniature with multiple cannons and adorned with golden skulls and ornaments on a cluttered workbench.
Terrain for Warhammer 40k that I painted for a client. A simple color scheme that required some planning to ensure consistency across the entire (huge) piece. This was a monstrosity of a model.

A kind of honeymoon period of the miniature painting service life

In the early (super fun) years of painting miniatures for other people, I didn’t charge much. What I was looking for was a group of people who enjoyed my work, thought that it worth a few dollars, and loved receiving my finished painted pieces.

Circle Horde miniature - A painted fantasy miniature of a bird-like creature with a staff, showcasing fine detail in a soft light against a rust-colored background.
The early days, I was incredibly happy with painting things at incredibly low prices to ensure I didn’t fail to meet expectations with my friends.

For the most part, my customers were from my local gaming group who I also played games with. The jobs were small, random pieces that challenged my ability to understand what colors worked together, and how to meet the expectations, the vision that my customers expressed to me.

Painting miniatures as an amateur commissioned painter was a rollercoaster of challenges with few risks other than investing a bit of my time and subtle fear of not meeting my friends’ expectations (although they were very low at the time….).

A colossal for Circle faction in Hordes wargame - A detailed miniature of a warrior in ornate armor standing on a rocky base, surrounded by paint pots indicative of the painting process.
Circle battle engine… a test of my skill in the days when I didn’t know as much about things like glazing or wet blending.

I loved it. Low expectations, great fun for all, and the challenge for a budding miniature painter/artist (me) to hone their skill across a huge range of miniatures, of all complexity, types, and colors schemes. I learned so much and I was able to pocket a bit of side change. Commissioned miniature painting funded both my hobby and personal growth.


Then…commissioned miniature painting became work, but I learned something really important

As I got better a painting minis, faster and notably improving the way I created the finished models, I started charging a bit more money. And, it actually became a pretty good sum that I ended up being able to use a lot of it to experiment with fancier tools and equipment, e.g., better airbrushes, quality paint brushes, and such. Much of this went into this site’s expansion in sharing what I learned about what works and doesn’t.

A Warhammer 40k Grey Knight Dreadknight - A miniature mechanical warrior with intricate details, posed on a dark backdrop, highlighting the precision painting of its components.
An oldie, but a goodie… first time using water effects in a way that I felt looked realistic enough for me to say “hey, check it out, look-y what I did!”.

Expectations leads to disappointment if left unchecked

But, as demand grew, so did expectations—mine and the people I painted for. And, because there’s a limited supply—there’s only one me—I started to really pick and choose what projects to accept. While this was nice for a while, as I worked on things that I felt showed off my skill or held a particular personal interest (like I wanted to paint purple Warhammer 40k Orks, and had that opportunity for a client), I slowly burnt out. I even wrote about why I stopped painting for money for a while.

Two desk lamps against black backdrop - A blurred image capturing the motion of lights, possibly a concept for representing the flow of time or speed in artwork.
With commissioned miniature painting money I was able to afford fancy things like dedicated art lamps. The Neatfi XL is still one of my main workhorses. The Redgrass Creative R9 task lamp is slowly emerging as a replacement.

Long story short, I discovered that I had fallen into the common painting service trap of putting external expectations and tying my finished outcome to monetary gain. Inside, I was painting not for personal enjoyment or a sense of growth in the art, but for the pay day and the grateful accolades for a customer well satisfied. My hobby, the art, had become “just a job”.

Blood angel space marines for warhammer 40k - wip - A close-up of red armored miniature soldiers being painted, with focused detailing on the headgear and weaponry.
Blood Angels space marines (Warhammer 40k commission wip)

Painting miniatures for money dampens the artistic freedom that comes with the art.

And, so I took a prolonged break from painting anything. Just stopped cold. It hurt, and maybe there was a depression in there. Just too much pressure and not enough spark to ignite the thing that makes us feel good about the hobby itself. I kind of withdrew for a bit.

Eventually I came out of it, painting much more now, but here’s the lesson learned: Be wary of turning your hobby into a business, unless you’re prepared to endure it as a business.


The Best Reason to Paint Miniatures for Money (IMHO)

With the exception for those of you who may be painting for a company or studio, or need the side-income, and it is actually your way of living, I think the best reason to paint miniatures for money is to measure your skill against an established point of reference—what someone else is willing to pay you for your services.

Shadowsword Astra Militarium Tank warhammer 40k - An expertly painted armored tank miniature in a dark setting, displaying weathering effects and battle insignias.

In other words, I think painting miniatures is a good way to understand your progress in the hobby. When you try to sell your service, your effort, you see your outcome from an different perspective. You have to view your work through the lens of another person. And the more people you do work for, the more varied the perspectives you have.

Menoth Warmachine Colossal Judicator - A golden armored giant miniature, painted with a high level of craftsmanship, set against a textured backdrop.

Painting miniature for money helps you grow in skill. It pushes your boundaries of what you think you’re capable of, because you’re forced to meet an expectation. Painting miniatures on commission also places a deadline on your work. You won’t have the luxury of procrastination.

Learning to paint well ultimately requires you to finish the project to the best of your ability, or at least match someone else’s desired outcome. In either case, agreed upon transaction between service provider and client serves as a bridge to creates a relationship you can use to gauge your artistic character—the part of you that fears, loves, and endures to create (and finish) whatever final painted miniature you’re working on.

Deep down, with discipline—avoiding the trap of making it a job—I think painting miniatures for money makes you a better artist.


Conclusion

So, what do you think? Do other people pay you to paint miniatures? I hope you’re enjoying the process. Anyway, this was just my two cents into how I’m coming around to how I would like to approach commissioned miniature painting moving forward. The entire hobby has been a journey into understanding who I am as a person, a creator, and how much I enjoy sharing what I learn along the way.

Until next time, happy miniature painting! Let me know what you think with a comment below or write to me directly!

Enjoying Your Visit? Join Tangible Day

Free newsletter with monthly updates (no spam)

Leave a comment! Follow on X, Instagram, and Facebook.

Free photo backdrop bundle for miniature photography - tangible day - backgrounds for photographing miniatures - free gift image
Grab your FREE photo backdrop bundle for miniature photography in the shop.
135 Unique Hobby Gift Ideas: Fast 2 Days or Less Shipping!
Favorite tabletop miniature and wargaming finds on etsy - tabletop miniature and wargamer favorites on etsy image
Best Alternative to Winsor & Newton Series 7 Brushes for Painting Miniatures - cheap sable kolinsky sable brushes for painting miniatures - good budget brushes for painting miniatures - blick masterstroke brush for model paint
DriveThruRPG banner for the largest RPG download database store

Tangible Day on YouTube (Miniatures and More!)

Tangible Day on YouTube follow image flash screen

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Tangible Day

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading